15 April 2011

Press Release - NGO Platform: Bangladesh Succumbs to Shipping Industry Pressure

Temporarily Allows Toxic Ships

Pending Final Ruling In a judgment on Monday 7 March 2011, the Bangladesh High Court has granted temporary permission to Bangladesh shipbreaking yard owners to resume importing toxic ships for breaking on the beaches near Chittagong, Bangladesh. This temporary lifting of the beaching ban for toxic ships was taken as the Supreme Court still needs to rule on the pre-cleaning of toxic ships and frame the rules that will apply to shipbreaking, reports the NGO Shipbreaking Platform.

The High Court ruled in March 2009 that only toxic waste-free ships would be able to lawfully enter Bangladesh due to that country’s obligations as Party to the Basel Convention. The Basel Convention places strict controls on all imports of hazardous waste. In August 2010, the Court once again reaffirmed its judgment and most shipbreaking activities came to a standstill. The unlawful entry of ships containing toxic materials into Bangladesh was exposed by the Bangladesh Environmental Lawyers Association (BELA), a member of the NGO Shipbreaking Platform who took the matter to court. As a result, BELA won the groundbreaking rulings acclaimed by environmentalists worldwide.

In January and February, the Bangladesh Shipbreakers Association (BSBA) went to court to allow the import of ships for breaking. Today, their appeal was accepted by the Court under certain conditions. The Court ordered all workers to be trained and for all shipbreaking activities to be monitored by a team of experts. But these conditions are considered merely aesthetic by the NGO Shipbreaking Platform because they do not bring any real changes to the business model of the shipbreaking industry in Bangladesh that is currently polluting the country's coastal zones and putting the workers and the surrounding communities’ lives in danger. Though the training of the workers is important, breaking ships directly on beaches can never be done in a safe and environmentally sound way. (See http://www.offthebeach.org/)

“It is clear that the court is under a lot of pressure from the shipbreakers and the government of Bangladesh as well. Declaring shipbreaking as an industry last month, the government seems to be pressured by monied interests that are in favor of the industry reopening with no necessary changes first taking place”, said Rizwana Hasan, attorney for BELA.

BSBA rested its case on a series of completely erroneous information filed with the court, including assertions that toxic substances PCBs, asbestos and TBT were no longer found on ships currently being sent for scrap. In fact, maritime experts around the world have calculated that significant amounts of
asbestos and TBT will likely be found in recycling operations at least until 2045, and PCBs at least until 2015.

Asbestos, PCBs and TBT cause severe chronic or acute toxicity and occupational disease such as mesothelioma. An unknown number of workers succumb to long-term exposures of such hazardous materials. More well documented are the frequent deaths in the Bangladeshi shipbreaking yards due to fire and explosions caused by flammable gases and oily residues left in the tankers. In fact, since August 2010, even when most shipbreaking yards have been closed and only a minimum amount of breaking has been taking place, ten workers were killed in accidents.

The greater case that will decide on the pre-cleaning of ships issue is still pending in the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court. “The NGO Shipbreaking Platform believes that Bangladeshi courts will yet find the courage of conviction and uphold established law. The courts must distinguish between exploitation and employment, profiteering from the long-term welfare of Bangladesh,” said NGO Shipbreaking Platform Director, Ingvild Jenssen. “In any case, the matter will never rest in the greater court of public opinion, as long as such a devastating affront to human rights and the environment is allowed to continue in South Asia.”

March 2009

NGO Shipbreaking Platform - Press release: Bangladesh to become ship graveyard if nothing is done

In a judgment on Monday, 7 March 2011, the Bangladesh High Court granted temporary permission to shipbreaking yard owners to resume importing toxic ships for breaking on the beaches near Chittagong, Bangladesh. The Court order includes various conditions that must be fulfilled before the yards can resume the actual breaking of the ships.

The Court seems to be steering the shipbreaking industry in the right direction, and many of the requirements are welcomed steps towards ensuring bettered conditions at the shipbreaking yards. But the Platform warns that the judgment's effect may be catastrophic because the changes will not be structural, but merely cosmetic.

Understanding what the Court order actually implies has left many confused. Bangladeshi shipbreaking yards will be allowed to import the ships but will not be allowed to start breaking them until all conditions are met.

While some of the Court’s conditions, such as setting up compulsory training courses for workers and banning child labour are a decisive step forward, the order fails to address the overarching issue of beaching. It is very important to underline that breaking toxic ships directly on the shifting grounds of tidal beaches can never be done in a safe and environmentally-sound way. Beaches cannot support the weight of cranes or emergency equipment, making it a very risky work environment. The dangerous pollutants released from the ships seep into the sand and into the water, destroying the ecosystems and the livelihoods of locals.

Additionally, toxic materials are still being allowed into Bangladesh, which is illegal and ignores Bangladesh's obligations as Party to the Basel Convention.

This exact issue, concerning the ore-cleaning of ships, remains pending in the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court. Two earlier rulings have stated that only toxic free end-of-life ships are allowed to enter Bangladesh. In the meantime, following the judgment of March 7th 2011, many more obsolete toxic ships will be beached on the coasts of Bangladesh, turning the beaches into ship graveyards. Or worse, illegal breaking will spin out of control as the parties involved will look for ways to do business as usual.

The NGO Shipbreaking Platform remains optimistic however that the Appellate division of the Supreme Court will distinguish between exploitation and employment, profiteering from the long-term welfare of Bangladesh and put a halt to this dirty and dangerous practice that is shipbreaking on the beach. In the meantime, ship owners need to be aware that any sales to Bangladeshi shipbreakers today will turn beaches into ever-growing graveyards of toxic ships and will only worsen an ongoing human rights and environmental disaster.

Source: NGO Shipbreaking Platform 10 March 2011
http://www.shipbreakingplatform.org/v2/?page=v2/news/37/15/Bangladesh-to-become-ship-graveyard-if-nothing-is-done/

Press Release: Environment Agency demands strict green standards in recycling French naval ship

For immediate release – 5 February 2009


The Environment Agency have put in place the some of the world’s most rigorous regulatory controls to ensure that the former French naval vessel – the Q790 (formerly Le Clemenceau) - is dismantled and recycled in a safe and environmentally sound manner. The Q790 set off from Brest in France on Tuesday and is due to arrive at Able UK Limited’s recycling facility at Graythorp in Hartlepool over the weekend.

Able UK Limited’s facilities have been meticulously assessed before permits with stringent conditions were issued last year, allowing the dismantling of waste ships and offshore structures in a dry-dock in a manner that will not cause harm to the environment or to human health.

These environmental permits include:

• Environmental Permit (Waste Management Licence) to allow ships to be dismantled and recycled at Graythorp (determined June 2008),

• Five Consents to Discharge – two for permission to discharge site drainage, two for treated sewage and one for trade effluent (determined March 2008),

• Work in Rivers consent, which allows Able UK to do work in the river (determined February
2008).

• A non-native species assessment of the vessel to ensure there is no marine growth that can be introduced and cause harm in the Tees estuary (January 2009).

The Environmental Permit was issued following a public consultation and after Planning Permission was secured from Hartlepool Borough Council in 2007.

Environment Agency North East Environment Manager, Bob Pailor said: “In 2006, the Clemenceau was destined to be dismantled in India in appalling conditions for workers and the environment.

“The Clemenceau is now to be dismantled at the Able UK facility which has some of the world’s most rigorous regulatory controls to ensure this vessel is dismantled and recycled in an environmentally sound manner. For instance, we are not aware of another country that requires a non-native species assessment before a waste ship movement takes place.

“The Environment Agency will police site operations to ensure the company complies with permit conditions to protect people and the environment. We have a range of Enforcement and Prosecution powers at our disposal if we detect operations are not being carried out in accordance with the permit conditions.”

Environmental regulations

An Environment Permit authorises the keeping, treatment, or disposal of controlled waste. Such licences contain conditions that the operator must comply with to ensure that waste management operations do not pollute the environment, cause harm to human health or serious detriment to local amenities.

Hartlepool Borough Council granted planning permission to Able UK in 2007 and the rigorous technical assessment of their Environmental Permit application utilised significant public consultation, seeking views from local people on the level of protection the licence affords.

Mr Pailor said: “Some conditions were altered as result of the public consultation. For example, one respondent suggested that inspection of the dry-dock floor should be independent of Able UK. We agreed with this suggestion and an ‘appropriately qualified third party’ must now carry out the inspection.”

Around 94% of the ship of the 27,000-tonne vessel will be recycled and any residual hazardous material, such as asbestos, must be handled and disposed of in accordance with the strict conditions of the Environmental Permit.

The Environment Agency will work closely with other regulatory authorities – Health and Safety Executive, Hartlepool Borough Council, PD Ports and the Marine Fisheries Agency – to ensure compliance with permit and planning conditions ensuring that people and the environment are not harmed by Able UK’s operations. The regulators will share information to ensure standards are being met.

Waste ship movements

Under European Waste Shipment Regulations (WSR), the French Naval Support Service – Service de Soutien de la Flotte (SSF) – needed to secure consent for the movement of the ship from both the Environment Agency and the counterpart French regulator DRIRE Bretagne, before moving the ship from Brest in France.

Following confirmation that all permits and licences were in place, the Environment Agency consented on 26 November 2008 to allow SSF to move the Q790 from Brest in France to Able UK Limited’s facilities at Graythorp, Hartlepool for dismantling and recovery.

Under European Waste Shipment Regulations, recovery of ships must take place within 12 months of the vessels arrival at the recovery facility. Worldwide ship recycling standards Meanwhile, the United Kingdom’s influence has been at the forefront of developing worldwide standards for ship recycling.

The Marine Environment Protection Committee (MEPC) of the International Maritime Organization (IMO) expects a ship recycling convention to be adopted at a conference in Hong Kong in May.

The new convention will provide regulations for the design, construction, operation and preparation of ships to facilitate safe and environmentally sound recycling, and the establishment of an appropriate enforcement mechanism for ship recycling, incorporating certification and reporting requirements.

IMO has co-operated with the International Labour Organization and the relevant bodies of the Basel Convention on ship recycling in developing the new draft convention.

For more information visit http://www.environment-agency.gov.uk/.

ENDS


Media enquiries: 020 7863 8710 or outside normal office hours, please contact the National Duty Press Officer on 07798 882 092.
Media enquiries: 0113 231 2381 / 2464 / 2373 or outside normal office hours, please call 0800 80 70 60.

Greenpeace media briefing: ‘START’ SHIP RECYCLING IN BRITAIN

March 2004

Background

Greenpeace has been campaigning on the issue of shipbreaking for almost 10 years. The campaign has centred on scrapping yards in Bangladesh, Pakistan and in particular the yard in Alang, India. Alang is situated in Gujarat province, in the North West corner of India, 300 miles North of Mumbai on India’s North West coast.

What is shipbreaking?

After an average of 25-30 years (normally slightly longer for naval vessels) ships are at the end of their sailing life. These ‘End of Life Vessels’ are sold and dismantled to recover the valuable steel. About 95% of the ship consists of steel, but they also contain large amounts of hazardous materials.

In the 1970s shipbreaking was concentrated in Europe. Performed at docks, it was a highly mechanised industrial operation. But the costs of upholding environmental, health and safety standards increased. So the shipping industry moved to poorer Asian states that have few health and safety standards

Every year around 600-700 larger sea vessels are taken out of service and taken to Asia for scrap. In the 1990s they had an aggregate tonnage of around 15 million dead weight tonnes (dwt) a year. In 2001 the total number of vessels (608) sold for scrap totalled 28 million dwt. (Source E.A. Gibson Shipbrokers).

How are ships scrapped in Asia?

Ships are scrapped by poor workers earning between US $1.50 and $2.50 per day. They break the ships with torch cutters and their bare hands - unprotected from toxic substances, explosions and falling steel. Many are injured or killed by suffocation or explosions. Many are expected to contract cancer due to asbestos dust. According to a European Commission report, "manual, low paid workers are allowed to dismantle the ships without the provision of safety equipment, and scant attention is paid to health and safety issues or training. Injuries and deaths are common place". (Commission of the European Communities Technological and Economic Feasibility Study of Ship Scrapping in Europe. Report no. 2000-3527 Revision no. 01, 2001)

Most of the ships dismantled today were built in the 1970's, prior to the banning of hazardous materials like PCBs and asbestos. On the Asian beaches these toxic substances are released into the environment and workers’ bodies. If not regulated properly, the shipbreaking industry can be one of the most deadly in the world.

Asbestos

Exposure to asbestos fibres through inhalation may cause cancer and asbestosis. On the shipbreaking beaches of Asia asbestos fibres and flocks fly around in the open air. Men take out asbestos insulation materials with their bare hands. They dry it in the sun, so they can sell it.

Asbestos dust causes formation of scar-like tissues in the lungs. This results in permanent breathing difficulties such as asbestosis. In the longer term it can lead to mesothelioma which is a cancer of the thin membrane surrounding the lungs.

UK naval ships scrapped in India

The Ministry of Defence has sold UK naval ships to scrap merchants which then ended up in India. In 2000 two Royal Naval vessels – the ‘Olwen’ and the
‘Olna’ (1) ended up being broken on the beaches at Alang in India. This was after the ships were rejected by the Turkish Government because of the levels of toxic material onboard.(2) Environmental safeguards are nonexistent in Alang and there is almost no safety equipment for a workforce that includes children. The ships were originally sold to German Shipbreaking Company Eckhardt, who sold the ships on.

The UK Government owns 107 large vessels comprising 3 aircraft carriers, 1 amphibious ship, 11 destroyers, 21 frigates, 22 mine counter measure vehicles, 23 patrol vessels, 1 ice patrol vessel, 3 hydrographic vessels and 22 auxiliaries.

Currently HMS Intrepid (3) – an amphibious landing vessel – is berthed at Portsmouth awaiting a decision about its disposal. HMS Intrepid contains 40 tonnes of asbestos as well as PCBs, lead and heavy fuel oil (4).

UK Shipping Register

More than 1,700 vessels weighing over 100 gross tonnes, are listed on the UK shipping register. 800 of these are over 500 gross tonnes. The UK derives significant economic benefit from shipping interests. Despite this, UK ships are not currently decommissioned or recycled in the UK but are sent to places like Alang in order to save costs. The UK vessel the Genova Bridge was beached in Alang, India in November 2003

START Ship Recycling in Britain

Peter Mandelson MP, Greenpeace and the GMB call on the UK Government to:

• UK Government to support the development of purpose-designed and built, state of the art ship recycling facilities in Britain.

• An immediate public commitment that British Government owned vessels will be entirely recycled within the EU at state of the art facilities. This commitment could be made immediately and should include HMS Intrepid.

• The Government should seek to persuade British ship owners to recycle their vessels at state of the art facilities within the EU and must urgently explore ways of compelling all EU ship owners to dispose of their ships at such facilities.

Notes

1) Before being taken out of service the Olwen and Olna were the two oldest and largest fast fleet tankers in the Royal Fleet Auxiliaries (RFA) flotilla, having entered RFA service in 1965 and 1966 respectively. Known as O class fuel replenishment ships, They were used for refuelling and resupplying navy ships at sea. They last put to sea in July 1999 and November 1999 respectively. They were replaced by two new large fleet tanker ships RFA Wave Knight, the Wave Class, built by BAE Systems for the United Kingdom Royal Fleet Auxiliary. Wave Knight was commissioned in March 2003 and Wave Ruler in April 2003.

2) The Olwen and Olna were bought by a German company called Eckhardt. The ships left the port of Portsmouth in the UK in February 2001 and were sold by Eckhardt to a Turkish scrap yard. The Turkish Ministry of Environment prohibited the import of the ships. Eckhardt then towed the ships to a Greek port, renamed them Kea and Kos and moved them through the Suez Canal to Alang in India where they arrived in July 2001.

3) HMS "Intrepid" is an amphibious landing vessel, built in 1967 by John Brown & Co. (Clydebank) Ltd. The vessel has been laid up since the early '90s and is currently berthed at HMNB Portsmouth.

According to information leaked to Greenpeace, a 2001 British Navy inventory of asbestos on HMS "Intrepid" reportedly found asbestos throughout the vessel, including asbestos insulation on pipework throughout the ship and the insulation on the 2 funnels. Further finds were in starter boxes, flange gaskets, deck-head lighting, electrical heaters and fire curtains.

4) Source for statistics: Ministry of Defence.

Hyundai Mipo to benefit from increased small-ship scrapping:

Hyundai Mipo Dockyard, the world's fifth largest shipbuilder will benefit from increased small-ship scrapping, a South Korean brokerage said Thursday.

"The biggest beneficiary of the rising scrap rates will be Mipo, as most of the old vessels being scrapped are small ones, which are Mipo's specialty," Lee Sok-je, a shipbuilding analyst at Mirae Asset Securities, said in a report.

In the first three months of 2011, the number of bulk carriers scrapped has quadrupled on-year, amounting to 4.3 million deadweight tons, according to the report. The scrap volume in the first quarter reached as much as 82 percent of that for the whole 2010 and was the third-largest quarterly scrapping volume in history.

Mirae Asset expected the scrapping cycle to speed up, led by small bulk carriers going forward because the portion of ships over 15 years old is largest among small bulk carriers and the upcoming regulations on carbon dioxide emissions is forcing inefficient vessels out of the market.

"Ship owners have to consider replacing their old vessels ahead of further rallying of new building prices supported by higher steel prices and strengthening Asian currencies," Lee said.

Hyundai Mipo has been regarded as a PC tanker-focused shipyard, but it actually builds every type of small ships ranging from bulk carriers to LPG carriers, Lee said, stressing that the South Korean shipyard has the strength of flexibility in its product mix which competitors can not match.

"Hyundai Mipo can change its product mix frequently in line with market demand to maximize its profitability," Lee added.

Source: Xinhua. April 14, 2011
http://english.peopledaily.com.cn/90001/90778/90858/90863/7350622.html