01 April 2011

Question and Answer about ShipBreaking in European Parliament:

Parliamentary questions:
14 February 2011

Question for written answer
to the Commission
Rule 117
Georgios Koumoutsakos (PPE) and Konstantinos Poupakis (PPE)


Subject: Safe shipbreaking  

Every year, about 1000 vessels of all types are taken to shipbreaking yards, where approximately 95% of their metals are recovered. Tighter rules on safety and environmental protection in western markets have shifted shipbreaking activities to coastal areas in southern Asia. According to the NGO Platform on Shipbreaking, shipbreaking conditions in these areas violate minimum standards of protection of workers and respect for the environment.

Bearing in mind the 2007 Green Paper on Better Ship Dismantling and the guidelines of the International Labour Organisation and the International Maritime Organization on ship recycling, will the Commission say:

— How could it provide enhanced technical assistance to countries where shipbreaking takes place?

— Within the framework of effective cooperation with those countries, does it consider it appropriate and useful to propose setting up a network of EU-approved shipbreaking yards?

— Does it consider that ship recycling is economically viable and, if so, how could it be combined with respect for environmental standards and the appropriate health and safety rules at work?


Answer(s)

E-1140/11EN
Answer given by Mr Potočnik
on behalf of the Commission
(11.3.2011)

The Commission has adopted an EU Strategy for Better Shipdismantling in 2008. It welcomes the adoption of the Hong Kong Convention on Safe and Environmentally Sound Recycling of Ships and supports its early implementation and ratification. In addition, the Commission supports the development of a set of technical guidelines aiming to ensure a safe and sound recycling of ships through IMO's Maritime Environmental Protection Committee (MEPC). In order to accelerate the entry into force of the Hong Kong Convention, the Commission has taken steps encouraging Member States to ratify it.

As announced in this Strategy, the Commission has launched a study to examine the feasibility of establishing a list of green and safe recycling facilities[1] and will continue to assess the feasibility of this option. The Commission also supports international developments on this issue. For instance, the IMO Secretariat has organised a series of workshops with participants from major recycling countries. In addition, IMO, ILO and the Secretariat of the Basel Convention have set up a Global Programme for sustainable ship recycling in order to streamline their actions and avoid duplication of work in recycling countries.

The economics of the ship dismantling industry and the dynamics of the business cycles within the shipping sector is a very complex matter, because a wide range of factors influence the fluctuations of the prices in the different markets of this sector. The ship dismantling market has been explored in a study launched by the Commission to examine the implications of the accelerated phase-out scheme of single hull tankers[2]. While ship dismantling may be vital for the economies of certain countries, this sector needs to be transparent, environmentally friendly and above all safe working conditions must exist. A number of ship-owners have already taken the step to recognise their responsibilities and have chosen to invest in green and safe recycling facilities.


Source:

Derelict vessel to be enclosed by cofferdam, scrapped:

Contractors are now planning to dismantle the beached and broken Davy Crockett right where it sits.

Photo by
Steve Lane
Workers will encircle the 431-foot barge with a cofferdam, forming an enclosed area, and take it apart piece by piece. The original plan of floating it away to a dry dock proved to be untenable, marking another setback in an operation that’s already the most expensive shipwreck in Washington history.

Until this week, federal and state authorities had been planning to cut the ship in two and float both halves away to a dry dock.

But officials said they were unable to reach agreements with local shipyards.

“Unfortunately, the efforts to gain utilization of the local dry docks for destruction of the Crockett were unsuccessful due to a litany of safety, complex environmental and liability issues,” U.S. Coast Guard Capt. Daniel LeBlanc said.

Instead, contractors will encircle the vessel with 850 feet of metal sheet pilings to allow workers to safely dismantle the ship while containing pollution.

Construction of the cofferdam will begin as soon as Friday.

The sheet pilings and a secondary silt barrier will enable contractors to cut apart the Crockett while minimizing the risk of PCB-tainted oil or bunker fuel escaping into the river, state and federal officials said in a conference call on Monday.

But it will be expensive.

The operation had already consumed $9.5 million as of Monday, LeBlanc said, and it currently has the ability to tap another $4 million.

Costs have risen throughout the saga, which began two months ago after the Coast Guard ordered owner Brett Simpson of Ellensburg to remove oil and garbage aboard the damaged ship. Simpson had been attempting to scrap the vessel while it was afloat, but the process caused it to buckle and partially sink.

On Jan. 27, three days after the Coast Guard assumed Simpson complied with its order, oil-spill specialists with the state Department of Ecology traced a sheen 15 miles upriver to the Davy Crockett.

The Coast Guard then federalized the response.

The cleanup is being funded by the Oil Spill Liability Trust Fund, a federal fund created by a tax on petroleum products. Simpson has not participated in the cleanup and is the subject of a parallel investigation by federal authorities.

LeBlanc said officials won’t have a final cost estimate at least until the lead contractor — Seattle-based Ballard Diving & Salvage — submits a formal destruction plan later this week.

“Once we get the plan for the destruction phase, that will give us a better idea,” LeBlanc said. “Following the removal of the vessel, we will then have a disposal plan for steel and oily water, a follow-up sampling of sediment within the cofferdam and remediation cost to restore the environment in that location.”

The contractor’s best estimate was to finish the operation in 16 weeks, LeBlanc said.

Ron Holcomb, on-scene coordinator for the Washington Department of Ecology, said Ballard has been asked to procure the biggest possible crane to reduce the number of cuts. The idea is to load big chunks of the vessel aboard a waiting barge.

“This cofferdam, when installed, will provide a very high level of environmental protection around the Davy Crockett,” Holcomb said.

The sheet pilings are 3/8 of an inch thick, with 25-inch-wide interlocking joints. The joints won’t be watertight, but the cofferdam combined with the secondary nonpermeable silt barrier should effectively trap pollutants as contractors work. LeBlanc said the cofferdam will take 12 days to install.

Meanwhile, the Coast Guard is planning to set lighted buoys to designate a 300-foot safety zone around the vessel.

“We did have some encroachment of recreational fishermen a couple of weeks ago,” LeBlanc said. “Since the salmon season has kicked into gear now, we’re concerned about their safety and also the safety of the workers at the site.”

The recovery effort has already eclipsed the cost of removing the S.S. Catala from the beach at Ocean Shores in 2006.

That shipwreck actually occurred in 1965, but was exposed three decades later by shifting sands. When oil was discovered entombed aboard the 229-foot vessel, the state Department of Ecology embarked on what became the most expensive maritime cleanup in state history — $7.2 million.

The Davy Crockett is already costlier.

“It’s much more complicated here, where everything is on water,” Holcomb said.

Source: The Columbian. Eric Robinson (erik.robinson@columbian.com). Tuesday, March 29, 2011.

Ship recycling: UK Ship Recycling Strategy - Defra


In 2007, Defra issued  the UK Ship Recycling Strategy following reviews carried out by Defra (via the Ballard Review) and by the Environment Agency to identify lessons learnt after the import of four decommissioned US naval ships in 2003 and following recommendations made by the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee in its report “Dismantling Defunct Ships in the UK”. (For more information on these reports, please see The National Archives).

The Strategy establishes domestic policy for the recycling of UK Government-owned vessels, sets out relevant waste controls and makes recommendations for owners and operators of UK flagged vessels.  It encourages the development of further facilities to recycle ships in an environmentally sound manner within the UK.  It also informs the UK position on international work.

The Strategy is available in 5 languages beside English:

  • Chinese
  • French
  • German
  • Portuguese
  • Spanish
The Regulatory Impact Assessment that was issued alongside the Strategy can be viewed at: UK ship recycling strategy Final Regulatory Impact Assessment

Alongside the Strategy, Defra issued detailed guidance to provide ship owners and ship recyclers with clear, practical guidance on the regulatory regimes pertaining to ship recycling in the UK: Overview of ship recycling in the UK Guidance

The Hong Kong International Convention for the Safe and Environmentally Sound Recycling of Ships:

The Hong Kong Convention was adopted at an International Maritime Organization (IMO) diplomatic conference in May 2009, following over 3 and a half years work with input from IMO Member States and relevant non-governmental organizations in cooperation with the International Labour Organization and parties to the Basel Convention.

The Hong Kong Convention aims to ensure that end of life ships do not pose any unnecessary risks to human health, safety and the environment and aims to address all issues around ship recycling  from design and construction, through operation and  finally to recycling.  It will come into force once ratified (or signed without reservation as to ratification) by a sufficient number of states.  Pending its coming into force, the IMO is developing a raft of guidance to support the Convention.

More information on the Convention is available at:

International Maritime Organization:

In the UK, the Department for Transport leads on issues relating to the Hong Kong Convention with input from Defra.

An EU Strategy for Better Ship Dismantling:

In November 2008, in anticipation of the Hong Kong Convention, the European Commission published a Communication “An EU Strategy for Better Ship Dismantling”. The Strategy envisaged an integrated policy approach of implementing the key elements of the Hong Kong Convention, with the possibility of supplementing these requirements within the EU; taking measures to encourage voluntary action from the shipping industry pending the coming into force of the Convention; and considered the possibility of improving the enforcement of the current waste shipment law in relation to ships.

More information on the European Commission’s Strategy and subsequent work
In the UK, Defra leads on negotiations within the EU on this Strategy.

Page last modified: 30 March 2011

Source: Defra

An effort is underway to save the historic ship Olympia:

PHILADELPHIA - You could call it a battle cry to action. The Independence Seaport Museum, and a host of partners has issued an urgent call for the preservation of the Cruiser, Olympia for future generations.

"There's nothing like it in the world, and there never was anything quite like in the world," said Jesse Lebovics.

In fact, it is the world's oldest floating steel warship, and the only surviving naval ship of the Spanish American War.

In 1898, Olympia brought its big guns to bear upon the Spanish fleet in the Philippines. Commodore George Dewey and his flagship were Superstars that year as they crushed the Spanish fleet in Manila Bay in less than six hours.

It was the first decisive battle in the Spanish-American war, and it helped transform a young nation into a world power.

But that was more than a century ago.

"The Olympia is slowly, structurally decaying and our biggest fear is her potentially sinking of some other damage that would preclude her from ever being seen again," explains the ship's manager, Jesse Lebovics.

The ship is in critical need of hull and deck repair, and dry-docking, which is beyond the capacity of the Seaport Museum. It is seeking to transfer stewardship of Olympia to another organization.

"It's time for someone else to take care of the baby. We love her, but other people do also," said Captain John Gazzola.

The ship is safe for touring, which gives you a sense of extraordinarily unique maritime history.

"It also gives you a sense of what our forefathers sacrificed for us and future generations," said Captain Gazzola.

Not many museums give you the opportunity to stand on the artifacts.

"There's a lot of very hard work that goes into that," Captain Gazzola said.

Captain Gazzola says to ensure the long-term preservation of the Olympia, ownership of the vessel must be transferred to an able steward within two years, otherwise, officials would pursue scrapping or sinking the ship on a reef.

Source: By Lisa Thomas-Laury. Wednesday, March 30, 2011

29 March 2011

Agencies tread water on derelict vessels: Governments have little power until crisis level is reached


It’s not just barges that are causing headaches on the Columbia River this winter. Here, a smaller vessel is stranded on the piers of a wing dam off the eastern tip of Hayden Island. Vancouver’s Columbia Business Center is in the background.
PORTLAND — Another week, another stranded vessel on the Columbia River.

A small boat now teeters unevenly at the eastern tip of Hayden Island, impaled on the piers of a wing dam. It marks the latest in a spate of groundings over the past couple of months between Vancouver and Portland.

Authorities say this particular vessel doesn’t pose an immediate threat to the environment or river navigation.

“It’s safe, and it’s out of the channel,” said Multnomah County sheriff’s Deputy Jason Tyrus, a member of the sheriff’s river patrol unit.

Yet the vessel’s deteriorated condition may ultimately require a public agency to remove it.

Even though this boat’s plight doesn’t rise to the level of another more notorious shipwreck farther upriver, it does underscore the inability of public agencies to exercise control over festering problems on the water before they descend into crisis.

“What’s the appropriate role of the state or federal government whenever you’ve got private property that represents a threat to public safety or health — either because it’s weak structurally or it has materials on board that are hazardous?” said Jim Sachet, cleanup coordinator for the Washington Department of Ecology. “We have a process that takes time to play out … to give due process to vessel owners when they’re able to participate.”

Some owners are unable or unwilling to participate.

The 431-foot Davy Crockett, beached and broken on the north shore of the Columbia between Vancouver and Camas, is the most egregious local example. Contractors had burned through $7 million as of last week in the federal recovery operation, which began after the vessel’s owner walked away after partially scrapping the converted Liberty ship.

The Crockett, which languished virtually untended for two decades, is not the only vessel to raise warning flags among area boaters.

As the Crockett debacle began to unfold two months ago, longtime Vancouver-area boater Wayne Monroe observed that it’s not uncommon to see old boats fall into disrepair as they bounce between owners. Even owners with the best of intentions often find they lack the resources, interest or wherewithal to properly care for their boats.

Monroe recalled when it was simpler to dispose of vessels that had outlived their purpose.

“For years, boats have just been tied up against a bank someplace,” Monroe said. “It always used to be legal because no one cared about the river.”

Times are changing.

Just a few hundreds yards upstream from the Davy Crockett, the floating dock previously owned by the old Vancouver Yacht Club bobs up and down in the water against the north bank. Owner Rick Dulas reportedly purchased the assemblage for $1 from the Port of Camas-Washougal, which wanted to get rid of the vacant structure.

Dulas managed to tow it a few miles downriver before getting permission from an elderly shoreline owner to temporarily tie it up while he finalized plans for a permanent moorage near Jantzen Beach.

That was two years ago.


State agencies, the property owner and Clark County’s code enforcement office have been pressing since 2009 to have the structure removed.

Representatives of federal, state and local agencies say they have little authority to compel an owner to remove private property. As long as it isn’t actively leaking hazardous material into the water or blocking navigation, U.S. Coast Guard Capt. Daniel LeBlanc said his agency can’t just commandeer someone’s private property.

The Davy Crockett had been the subject of periodic complaints and at least one oil spill two years ago.

But LeBlanc said the Coast Guard had little cause to intervene until owner Brett Simpson jeopardized the integrity of the hull by cutting it apart late last year.

“It was a very minimal risk at that point in time because it was structurally sound,” LeBlanc said. “Had it not been for the actions of the owner, we would not have had a full-blown operation like we have now.”

Washington’s Department of Natural Resources operates a derelict vessel removal program, but it’s limited to boats of less than 200 feet in length, and its $1.7 million budget is stretched thin.

Across the river-

Oregon has only a fraction of Washington’s financial resources for derelicts, said Mike Greenburg, the Oregon Department of Environmental Quality’s on-scene cleanup coordinator for the Davy Crockett. Oregon can only act when a vessel constitutes an environmental or safety hazard — and only after it completely sinks.

The state has less than $200,000 annually to remove known derelicts. Identifying potential threats is a low priority.

“Those are underfunded programs,” Greenburg said, “and we are in the process of evaluating and researching what is out there in our river system.”

In light of the Davy Crockett debacle, Washington Gov. Chris Gregoire recently called for better coordination among state, local and federal agencies in identifying problematic vessels before they pollute the environment or prompt an expensive taxpayer-funded cleanup.

Regulators are keeping a close eye on another old barge previously owned by Simpson upriver at Dallesport. According to a citation by the Army Corps of Engineers, Simpson had illegally filled the river’s shoreline while scrapping the vessel across the river from The Dalles, Ore.

Lorri Epstein, water quality coordinator with the environmental group Columbia Riverkeeper, said the Department of Ecology assured her that the vessel seems relatively intact.

“Ecology says it’s not an immediate threat right now,” she said. “That’s great, but maybe we shouldn’t wait until it’s leaking.”

The boat impaled on the wing dam near Hayden Island doesn’t have much in the way of fuel on board and pales in comparison to the Davy Crockett, according to Terry Truan, dock master with the nearby Portland Yacht Club, who knows the owner. However, he said local authorities could have been more proactive in making sure the boat was securely anchored after the owner encountered a health problem.

“The Coast Guard and river patrol didn’t want to touch it,” Truan said. “When it breaks apart, which it will eventually, it’ll present a hazard,”
Source: The Columbian. By Erik Robinson (360-735-4551, or erik.robinson@columbian.com), Columbian Staff Reporter. Sunday, March 27, 2011

More like this